Buffalo nickels, minted between 1913 and 1938, have become prized possessions for coin collectors and enthusiasts alike. Known for their iconic Native American and buffalo designs, these nickels not only offer historical significance but also incredible value—some worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just checking your loose change, knowing which Buffalo nickels are valuable could lead to a surprising payday.
Here are 12 Buffalo nickels that are worth a fortune, ranked by their potential market value.
1. 1918/7-D Overdate Buffalo Nickel – Up to $350,750
At the top of the list is the rare 1918/7-D overdate nickel, which features a visible “8” struck over a “7.” This minting error is a dream for collectors. High-grade versions of this coin have sold for as much as $350,750 in auctions.
Source: Coin Value Checker
2. 1916 Doubled Die Obverse – Up to $281,000
This coin is easily identified by noticeable doubling on the obverse (front) side. It’s one of the most famous die errors in the Buffalo nickel series. Depending on condition, it can fetch $66,000 to $281,000.
Source: Coin Collecting Guide
3. 1926-S Buffalo Nickel – Up to $250,000
With only 970,000 coins minted, the 1926-S has the lowest mintage of the entire series. In mint condition, it’s extremely rare and can command prices of up to $250,000.
Source: Bullion Exchanges
4. 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo – Up to $150,000
This unique coin is famous for a minting error that left the buffalo with only three visible legs. Caused by over-polishing of the die, the 1937-D Three-Legged Nickel can sell for up to $150,000.
5. 1913-S Type 2 – Around $1,226
This is one of the earlier issues with the redesigned reverse where “FIVE CENTS” is recessed to reduce wear. The 1913-S Type 2 is particularly scarce and valued at $1,226 in high grade.
6. 1917-S – Around $1,318
With a modest mintage of 4.2 million, the 1917-S Buffalo nickel is tough to find in good condition. Collectors can expect to pay up to $1,318 for well-preserved examples.
7. 1920-D – Around $1,593
This Denver-minted coin often suffers from poor strikes and wear. High-quality versions of the 1920-D are rare and can be worth around $1,593.
8. 1919-D – Around $1,713
The 1919-D is a key date in the Buffalo nickel series and notoriously difficult to find in top condition. Values can rise to $1,713 depending on the grade.
9. 1920-S – Around $1,981
Less than 10 million of these San Francisco nickels were minted. As a result, mint-condition coins from this year can reach around $1,981 in value.
10. 1919-S – Around $1,981
With a limited number of uncirculated coins available, the 1919-S is considered highly collectible and often fetches up to $1,981.
11. 1925-S – Around $2,058
The 1925-S is usually found in poor condition due to heavy circulation. But pristine examples can reach prices of $2,058 or more.
12. 1927-S – Around $2,277
While more common than others on this list, uncirculated 1927-S nickels are still highly valued and can sell for $2,277.
Why Are These Nickels So Valuable?
The value of a Buffalo nickel depends on several factors:
- Mintage: The fewer produced, the rarer the coin.
- Condition: Coins in uncirculated or Mint State grades are far more valuable.
- Errors: Unique minting mistakes, like overdates or die polishing errors, drastically increase a coin’s worth.
- Historical significance: Early and transitional designs tend to attract collector interest.
To verify coin authenticity or value, you can refer to reputable sources like the U.S. Mint or the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS).
Final Thoughts
Buffalo nickels are more than just old coins—they’re miniature pieces of American history. With the right date, condition, and perhaps a little bit of luck, a single nickel could be worth thousands—or even hundreds of thousands—of dollars. So next time you’re sorting through pocket change or an inherited coin collection, keep an eye out. You might just find one of these hidden treasures.
Vikas is a seasoned finance writer with a keen eye for unraveling complex global financial systems. From government benefits to energy rebates and recruitment trends, he empowers readers with actionable insights and clarity. When he’s not crafting impactful articles, you can find him sharing her expertise on Social Media. You can connect with him via email at [email protected].
